Talk:Actors' Guild

From Discworld & Terry Pratchett Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Link to the Fool's Guild?

Just a thought but in The Truth it's stated Charlie (Vetinari's double) had entered the Guild of Actors and Vetinari foresaw a happy career for Charlie as a Vetinari-impersonator at children's parties and the likes. In Raising Steam on the otherhand Charlie is described as a clown, doing puppet shows and clowning when not officially taking Vetinari's place.

Considering this suggests he is indeed doing children's parties it raises a small question as where to draw the line between the guilds.

Come to think of it, using Roundworld as an example, many comedians are also actors [or is it many actors are also comedians?] (Catherine Tate, Billy Connolly, Stephen Fry, Rowan Atkinson, Hugh Laurie, Tony Robinson, Jim Carrey, Steve Coogan, Simon Pegg, Robin Williams, Charlie Chaplin, Armstrong and Miller, the boys of Monty Python: the list goes on and on!).

Historically there is also a blurring of the lines, with things like 'Commedia dell’arte' - which scarily went on to influence that unlawful act known as miming!

--Verity (talk) 19:21, 26 February 2014 (UTC)

Ah, another Demarcation issue... no doubt Vetinari would rule if the argument between Guilds threatened to get intense.

I guess the difference between Clowns and comic actors such as Cleese, Fry, Laurie, Atkinson, et c, is that the comic actors are more.... innovative and novel in their approach to comedy. They take risks, they are continually adding new jokes and routines, a good stand-up comedian would be continually adding new one-liners to his personal bespoke joke book... all those things which are anathema to the Guild of Fools. I'm surprised there hasn't been a street war in the manner of the Musicians' Guild hunting down unlicenced performers such as the Band... (Hmmm. Fanfic. This might breathe new life into a stalled story about rogue Clowns mounting a bid for power...) AgProv (talk) 22:56, 26 February 2014 (UTC)